How the Ledger rates programs
Each program receives one rating on each of three scales, taken from the program's statute, regulations, award terms, funding notices, guidance, official data catalogs and evaluations. Every rating cites the document and section it rests on, with the date it was read. The full rules are in the coding protocol and every column is defined in the codebook.
Required verification (R)
What recipients must report about results. This rates the obligation, not what happens in practice.
| 0 | Financial only | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Outputs | |
| 2 | Estimated outcomes | |
| 3 | Measured outcomes against a baseline | |
| 4 | Independent verification |
Public results (C)
What anyone can see. Award announcements and recipient lists are not results.
| 0 | No public results | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Aggregate only | |
| 2 | Project-level outputs | |
| 3 | Project-level outcomes | |
| 4 | Open machine-readable project data |
Attributability (A)
Whether the required or published data could let an outside party link outcomes to the funding.
| 0 | No baseline | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Baseline or modeled counterfactual only | |
| 2 | Measured before and after | |
| 3 | Comparison group or impact evaluation |
What the Ledger cannot tell you
- Public results measure publication, not collection. Agencies may hold outcome data they do not release.
- Version 0.1.0 covers 24 programs chosen to span agencies, funding types and assets. It is not a complete or random sample.
- The scales are ordinal. A gap of 2 is not twice a gap of 1.
- The Ledger rates program design, not whether any project saved energy.
The full list is in LIMITATIONS.md.
Data and citation
Download the tables for this version:
- vgl_programs.csv: one row per program with all ratings
- vgl_evidence.csv: one row per piece of evidence, with source links
- vgl_reference_sources.csv: sources that apply across programs
Cite this version: Akindipe, S. O. (2026). Verification Gap Ledger (Version 0.1.0) [Data set]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23302898
To cite the Ledger across versions, use the concept DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23302897
Releases follow a published schedule: 0.5 in February 2027, 1.0 in May 2027 and 2.0 in December 2027. Changes between versions are listed in the changelog.